top of page

Rethinking Youth Soccer in America: Emphasizing Skill Over Physicality

Updated: May 19


In American youth soccer, a significant shift is needed. While physical attributes like speed and size are often highlighted, prioritizing mental, technical, and tactical skills is crucial for the long-term development and success of young players. No one wants to lose but when you begin to prioritize that over the development of these important skill sets we begin to hinder the future success of these athletes.

The Misplaced Focus on Physical Maturity

Physical maturity often has a disproportionate impact on winning in youth sports. This is why it's frequently prioritized, as physically mature players tend to perform better in the short term. However, this focus can overshadow the importance of developing enduring skills.

Long-Term Player Development vs. Short-Term Wins

The emphasis on immediate physical dominance can hinder the development of fundamental skills and game understanding that are crucial for long-term success in soccer. In the long term everyone will eventually become physically mature, It's the players that have developed the technical skills from the earliest ages that will dominate the game, and the ones that relied solely on their physical attributes will be left in the dust.

The Detrimental Effects of Overemphasizing Winning

The overemphasis on winning in youth sports can have several negative consequences:

  • Increased Pressure and Stress: Around 80% of youth athletes experience burnout by age 13 due to overwhelming stress and pressure from the focus on winning​​.

  • Decreased Enjoyment: Excessive emphasis on winning can diminish the joy and delight associated with sports, leading to reduced participation rates​​.

  • Risk of Overuse Injuries: Overtraining, driven by the pursuit of victory, contributes to nearly half of all sports-related injuries in children​​.

  • Impaired Social Skills: An unhealthy atmosphere of fierce competition can hinder the development of teamwork and essential social skills among young athletes​​.

  • Lower Self-Esteem: Failure to win consistently can severely affect a child's self-esteem and overall confidence​​.

  • Neglected Personal Growth: A singular focus on winning can overshadow vital aspects of personal growth, discipline, and a love for learning​​.

  • Increased Bullying: A win-at-all-costs approach can contribute to a surge in bullying incidents among youth athletes​​.

A Balanced Approach

Combining Winning with Player Development: A balanced perspective on winning and player development is crucial. Winning should be seen as a part of the sport, but not the only goal. Research shows that young athletes prioritize playing time over winning, and their respect for coaches is not solely based on won-loss records, especially before puberty. Winning becomes more important as children grow older, but it should not overshadow the development of skills and enjoyment of the game​​​​.


The future of American youth soccer lies in a balanced approach that values skill development, mental strength, and tactical understanding as much as physical attributes. Emphasizing these aspects will not only create more skilled players but also ensure their well-being and love for the sport.

For further reading on this topic, please visit the links below.

Want to maximize your child’s soccer potential? Take a few moments to fill out our brief survey and join us in shaping a tailored soccer training experience. Your insights are the game-changer!

21 views0 comments


bottom of page